| Platinum | Pasta Garage Italian Cafe |
| Gold | Puccini's Pizza & Pasta |
| Silver | Bella Notte |
| Bronze | Giuseppe's Ristorante Italiano |
| Top Pick | Goodfella's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Joe Bologna's Restaurant and Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Sorella Gelateria |
| Top Pick | Sutton's Restaurant |